Step 1 of 8 · Getting Started

Free Employee Evaluation Form

Your answers save as you go. Legal form tools, not legal advice.

Free template

Download a free employee evaluation template

Free blank form—no account or payment required. The PDF is printable and the Word file is editable. This general version does not include state-specific clauses or disclosures.

Build a guided state-specific version
BusinessLast updated November 17, 20266 min read

What is an employee evaluation?

An employee evaluation is a written record of how someone performed over a set period. The manager who supervises the work (the reviewer) rates the employee in a handful of areas, looks back at the goals that were set, writes down what went well and what needs work, and agrees new goals with the employee. Both sign, and the form goes into the personnel file.

A good evaluation helps in three ways. Employees learn where they stand in plain terms, not from hints. Managers rate people in the same areas on the same scale, which keeps reviews fair across a team. And when a raise, a promotion or a performance problem comes up later, the company has a dated record of what it told the employee and when.

Evaluations sit alongside your other employment documents. Your employee handbook sets out the policies everyone follows, an employment contract covers the terms of a key hire, and a remote work policy sets the rules for people who work from home.

Key features
  • Five review types: annual, probationary period, mid-year check-in, project and improvement plan follow-up
  • A ratings table on a five-point scale with a written definition for each level
  • Eight standard competencies to choose from, plus up to two of your own
  • A results table for past goals (met, partly met or not met) and a table of new goals with target dates
  • Probation and improvement plan outcomes, including an extension to a new date
  • An employee comments space, with Connecticut and Illinois statement notices printed automatically
  • Signature lines for the employee, the reviewer and an optional second-level reviewer, ready for e-signature

Types of employee evaluations

The builder starts with one question: what kind of review this is. That choice sets the opening and adds the sections that review needs.

Annual review

The full look back at a year of work, with ratings, goals for the year ahead and an overall rating.

Create

Probationary period review

Records whether a new hire completed the probationary period, or extends it to a new date.

Create

Mid-year check-in

A shorter review halfway through the year to check progress on goals before the annual review.

Create

Project review

Rates the employee’s work on one named project, such as a system launch or a busy season.

Create

Improvement plan follow-up

Records whether the employee met the goals of a performance improvement plan, and whether the plan closes, continues or leads to next steps.

Create

When to use an employee evaluation

Use a written evaluation any time you want a clear, dated record of how someone is doing. Common moments:

  • The end of a new hire’s probationary or introductory period
  • Your yearly review cycle, or a mid-year check on goals
  • The end of a major project or assignment
  • The end of a performance improvement plan
  • Before a raise, promotion or change in duties
  • When a manager changes and the new one needs a baseline

What an employee evaluation should include

These are the sections our builder produces, in print order:

  • Review information: the employee, job title, department, reviewer, type of review, review period and date.
  • Rating scale: the five levels from Outstanding to Unsatisfactory, each with a short definition.
  • Competency ratings: a table with each area, its rating and comments.
  • Past goals: each goal for the period and whether it was met, partly met or not met.
  • Summary: the employee’s strengths and the areas to improve.
  • Probation or plan outcome: for those two review types only.
  • Next goals: a table of goals and target dates.
  • Overall rating: with optional comments and the date of the next review.
  • Employee comments: space to respond, plus any state notice.
  • Effect of the evaluation: it is not a contract and does not change the terms of employment.
  • Signatures: the employee (receipt, not agreement), the reviewer and an optional second-level reviewer.

Sample employee evaluation

The sample below shows a finished annual review, from the review information and ratings table through goals, the overall rating and the signature lines.

Preview the document your answers produce — then build your own in minutes.

Build my employee evaluation

Laws that touch performance reviews

No federal law requires a private employer to evaluate employees, and no state prescribes a review form. But reviews feed decisions about pay, promotion and discharge, so employment laws reach them. The builder prints the state rules below from the state you choose.

Rules that shape an employee evaluation

RuleWhat it means for a reviewSource
No discrimination in terms of employmentRatings that affect pay or other terms of employment cannot turn on race, color, religion, sex or national origin42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(a)(1)
Connecticut statement noticeA performance evaluation must tell the employee, in clear and conspicuous language, that they may submit a written statement if they disagree; the statement stays in the file and goes with any disclosure to a third partyConn. Gen. Stat. § 31-128e
Illinois statement of disagreementIf the employer and employee cannot agree to correct a record, the employee may submit a written statement that is attached and included when the record is released to a third party820 ILCS 40/6
California personnel recordsCurrent and former employees may inspect and copy performance records within 30 days of a written requestCal. Lab. Code § 1198.5
Montana discharge lawAfter the probationary period, a discharge not for good cause can be wrongful, so the Montana form drops the at-will statementMont. Code Ann. § 39-2-904

Other states have their own personnel file and employment rules. Check the law where the employee works.

Two habits make reviews more useful and easier to defend. Rate everyone in the same job on the same competencies and scale, and back each rating with an example from the review period. A comment like “closed 40 percent more tickets than the team average” says far more than “good worker”.

Reviews are evidence

An evaluation can end up as an exhibit in a pay, discrimination or discharge dispute. Write ratings and comments you would be comfortable explaining later, and talk to an employment lawyer before you rely on a review to support discipline or a discharge. LawVault provides documents and software, not legal advice, and we are not a law firm.

How to create your employee evaluation

You can download the free blank form and fill it in by hand, or answer the guided questions and let the builder assemble the evaluation for your review type and state.

  1. Pick the review type and stateChoose an annual, probation, mid-year, project or improvement plan review, then the state where the employee works.
  2. Name the employee and reviewerEnter the company, the employee’s name, title and department, and the reviewer’s name, title and the date of the review.
  3. Set the review periodEnter the dates the review covers, plus the project name, probation end date or plan date for those review types.
  4. Rate each competencyTick the areas to rate, add up to two of your own, and give each a rating from 1 to 5 with a short comment.
  5. Record goals and a summaryMark past goals as met, partly met or not met, describe strengths and areas to improve, and set goals for the next period.
  6. Give the overall ratingChoose the overall rating and, for a probation or plan review, the outcome. Add a date for the next review if you like.
  7. Sign and shareAdd an optional second-level reviewer, download a PDF or Word file, or send it for e-signature by the employee and the reviewer.

Meet with the employee to go through the evaluation, give them time to add comments, and keep the signed copy with any comments in the personnel file. Use the same form at every review so progress is easy to compare from one period to the next.

Common questions

It is a written performance review. A manager rates the employee’s work in set areas, records how the employee did on past goals, sums up strengths and areas to improve, sets goals for the next period and gives an overall rating. The employee signs to confirm receiving it and can add comments.

Yes. The PDF and Word files are free to download without an account. The PDF is a printable blank, not a fillable form; use the Word file or the guided builder to type your terms.

No. Our form says the employee’s signature confirms receipt only and does not mean the employee agrees. The employee can write comments on the form or attach a separate statement, and the company keeps it with the evaluation.

No federal law requires private employers to give performance reviews. Reviews are a management tool, but once you give them, anti-discrimination laws apply to how you rate people. Title VII bars discrimination in pay and in the terms, conditions or privileges of employment because of race, color, religion, sex or national origin (42 U.S.C. § 2000e-2(a)).

Our form always gives the employee room to comment. Some states make it a legal right. Connecticut requires a performance evaluation to tell the employee, in clear and conspicuous language, that they may submit a written statement if they disagree (Conn. Gen. Stat. § 31-128e), and Illinois lets an employee attach a statement of disagreement to a personnel record (820 ILCS 40/6). The builder prints those notices for those states.

It should not, and our form says so: the evaluation is not a contract and does not change the terms of employment. Montana is different. After an employee completes the probationary period, a discharge without good cause can be wrongful there (Mont. Code Ann. § 39-2-904), so the Montana version refers to that law instead of an at-will statement.

In some states, yes. California lets current and former employees inspect and get a copy of personnel records about their performance within 30 days of a written request (Cal. Lab. Code § 1198.5). Other states have their own personnel file laws, so check the rules where the employee works.

Yes. An evaluation has no special signing formalities, so the reviewer and the employee can sign electronically. Enter both names exactly as they will sign so the signature lines match.

Still unsure? Visit the help center.

Ways to get your employee evaluation

Answer the questions and preview the finished document free. You pay only when you’re ready to download, print or e-sign it, and you can choose how.

Free 7-day trial subscription Cancel anytime

$49/mo $0 for one week

Unlimited access to 210+ legal documents for 7 days. After the trial it renews at $49 a month unless you cancel at least 24 hours before it ends.

Start 7-day trial

Pro, billed yearly

$9.99/moBest value · Save 80%

Unlimited documents and edits, e-signature for every party, and the freedom to amend and re-issue at any time. Billed $119.88 a year and renews annually. Cancel anytime.

Start annual plan

Single document

$39One-time, no renewal

Unlock just this employee evaluation: a permanent PDF download, printing, e-signature for every party and a tamper-evident audit trail, with no subscription.

Build this document

Prices in USD. Free blank templates stay free. Compare plans or read the refund policy.

Build your employee evaluation in minutes

Preview the document your answers produce — then review, e-sign, or download it.

State-specific · E-sign ready · Legal form tools, not legal advice